THE GREAT WALTZ 1938
Last New Years I was watching the Vienna State Orchestra playing Strauss Waltzes in PBS and on came Tale Of The Vienna Woods. It was terrible and it was terrible because I am a fan of the 1938 MGM film THE GREAT WALTZ since I first saw it on the WCBS Late Show on the late 1950s.
Before I talk about the film’s Tale Of The Vienna Woods sequence let’s get a few things out of the way. First, the film itself is not the greatest movie MGM ever made; in fact far from it. It’s a failed attempt at an operetta style story in the form of an extremely fictionalized biography of Johann Strauss (the younger). In fact there is nearly nothing in the film that has anything to do with Strauss except the music and even here Dimitri Tiomkin and Oscar Hammerstein II wrote one of the songs in the film being palmed off as a Strauss effort. That pretty much says it regarding the historical accuracy of the movie.
Second Louise Rainer is absolutely wasted in this movie. Rainer was a very specialized actress. Like Garbo, she needed her films tailored to her strengths not her weaknesses. This worked in THE GREAT ZIEGFELD, DRAMATIC SCHOOL and even THE GOOD EARTH where her delicate, even fragile screen persona were key to making her characters shine. She was cast in THE GREAT WALTZ because, top billed, she was the only real star in a film which is, in truth, a showcase for Miliza Korjus, a brilliant coloratura soprano for whom THE GREAT WALTZ was her first film and especially designed to turn her into a movie star. But more on Korjus later. As such Reiner’s part as the always faithful, supportive but pretty dreary wife is underwritten, shallow and really needed more of a character actress to pump it up. Instead, it pretty much shows all of her weaknesses Rainer had as an actress.
OK, that out of the way.
The musical sequences are wonderful and they are as wonderful as they because Dimitri Tiomkin just off his landmark score for LOST HORIZON did the brilliant orchestrations.
(These Straus orchestrations were so wonderful that Tiomkin re-sued some of them 26 years later for the finale sequence of the Cinerama presentation of Samuel Bronston’s CIRCUS WORLD where I now heard his music in 5 track stereo during the films Roadshow Engagement.)
Strauss is played by Fernand Gravey, a star in France who came to Hollywood in 1937. Eventually signed by MGM he returned to France during the war to become a member of the secret French Army. After the war, now considered a national war Hero Gravey remained in his home country making films. Quite charming in this film, he pretty much suited the bill.
Miliza Korjus was an entirely different matter. Born In Poland but raised in Soviet Russia where she began her singing. Korjus managed to escape in the late 20s and soon began a European singing career which by the mid-30s made her one of the most celebrated coloratura sopranos on the continent. Irving Thalberg heard some of her recordings and immediately signed her to a long term MGM contract sight unseen. Although Thalberg died in 1936 Korjus didn’t make her film debut until 1938 and THE GREAT WALTZ. The wait was well worth it as the woman dominates the screen with her incredible singing, her looks and total screen charm. You can’t take your eyes off her. The woman is nothing less than magic and makes it understandable why she was such a sensation in Europe.
Not exactly on the light side (more a Mae West than a Janette MacDonald in terms of body size) nevertheless Adrian’s gowns hid the deficits and showed her off her assists to full advantage. She is so unexpectedly stunning that bringing her magic to the screen Korjus would receive an academy award nomination as best supporting actress for this, her first film. I have never heard coloratura like this. A true master she gives an unexpected sweetness to coloratura and, so, what is usually a technical demonstration, in her hands—or voice—makes for utter joy that you want to hear to her over and over again. It was this skill that made her as celebrated in Europe as she was.
The film was as lavish as any MGM musical of the period and in some cases even more lavish. Using sets left standing after Marie Antoinette completed filming it was still one of the most expensive films of the period and although it grossed as much as it cost it still lost 700,000 dollars—a massive sum in those days. The, film isn’t shown very much and, although pretty much forgotten today, for those who do see it, they revel in that wonderful music and of course Korjus. Frankly, I am thankful the film—for all its short comings—was made simply because I can see and hear her sing. If not for this film that pleasure might have been lost forever.
Which brings me to the brilliant 12 minute Tale OF The Vienna Woods Sequence. I have watched it over and over and will try my best to properly express what it achieves as it functions on multiple layers. The opening of the sequence which is often criticized has Gravey and Korjus by circumstance in a hired open carriage driven by an elderly driver. It is morning and the two—although attracted to each other—show each other nothing but disdain. That is until Gravey hears a bird singing and gets the beginning of an idea for a melody. Other sounds come into play and Gravery begins to add them as he develops it into the principle theme for the famous waltz Tale of The Vienna Woods. In the process Korjus gets caught up in the experience and adding her brilliant coloratura voice it soon seems that the entire forest joins in the exultation of artistic creation. Completed the two—who were standing as the music built and then finally ended—fall back into their seats exhausted as if having just experienced some form of emotional ecstasy.
The major complaints of many critics to this opening is that this is not how a musical piece is created—being given the music in bits and pieces by surroundings sounds. But that’s not the point. What is, is that we are seeing and, more importantly, hearing how a composer takes bits and pieces and builds them into a melody. It may be happening in his head and not in the Vienna woods, but the process is the same. Bits and pieces being skillfully added together to formulate a coherent and fully realized piece of music. It is my belief that, created by composers and musicians, this opening sequence was too sophisticated for its critics who found the on screen inspiration for the music inauthentic. In short, they just didn’t get.
In terms of the film’s story this opening sequence works on another level. It is the music that brings the composer and the opera singer together communicating in a form that speaks to both of them. Thus, what we are seeing and understanding are the reasons for an impending love affair. As musical artists, it is through music that the can communicate completely on a level that non musicians can never understand. This theme is carried through the rest of the sequence.
From the Vienna woods in the early morning the film dissolves to the late evening and a beer garden with an adjacent inn where Strauss—in a bandstand—is now working with a small female orchestra. During the intervening time—which was the bulk of the day—he was orchestrating the piece until it a completed and fully realized orchestral piece. As this process would be bore an audience, as two comic characters exchange dialogue we see Strauss in the background as he pauses the music to instruct one of the performers. All this is done so that if you aren’t looking you won’t even notice. But it is there From this point until the dizzying climax of the sequence Tiomkin’s orchestrations, re-juxtapositions and even music of his own to slightly augment Strauss, the composer/arranger subtly services both the music and the film.
So, while Strauss is working with the orchestra, Korjus is in one of the inn’s rooms finishing cleaning her gown and putting on her hat. The owner’s wife, mistaking her for Strauss’s wife, comments about how wonderful it must be to be married to an artist and especially Johann Strauss and Korjus agrees.
At this point what we are hearing—and this is all due to Tiomkin—is the Strauss music orchestrated and played as a love theme. While looking out the window blinds at Strauss playing his violin while conducting his orchestra, Korjus’s face radiates with love. It is music connecting one artist to another.
(It should also be noted that the black& White photography here as with the rest of the sequence is superb earned the film’s photographer an academy award nomination)
Koljus appears at the inn’s entrance and downstairs and sits to the side while Gravey plays the violin as the orchestration allows for a virtuoso violinist to display his skill (Gravey couldn’t play a note. It was dubbed in by a real musician) Suddenly Korjus begins singing (with Lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein) and the orchestration returns the music to a love theme and then transforms again as her singing and the musical accompanying becomes an operetta aria as Korjus stands and moves around the band stand once again displaying her coloratura skills mixed in with the Hammerstein lyrics.
Reaching Strauss, their two faces close, as he plays the violin and she sings to him the music makes them seem as one. The photography is particularly beautifully here and watching it made me feel I was seeing two people making love with music. Then suddenly Gravey hands off his Violin and the two begin to waltz. Slowly at first and then as the orchestration changes to a full throated rendition of Waltz their dancing increases in speed as they twirl around the bandstand over and over as the dancing becomes more and frenetic and the two become enraptured by sheer the passion of it. Soon Koljus is no longer singing lyrics but, but instead, pure coloratura which becomes like another instrument adding to the effect of the scene. This goes on for quite a bit as they dance around and around in sheer exultation until the music ends and in total exhaustion the two fall together on the grass with each looking at the other knowing how much in love with the other.
It is a thrilling 12 minutes of brilliantly conceived and brilliantly executed music that serves the eye, the ear and most of all the purpose of this sequence—a love scene. Watching the last moments of the sequence I felt, metaphorically of course, that I was watching two people in the act of love. Thus, the total sequence is nothing less than exalting.
Korjus was scheduled to make another film at MGM but was in a car accident which crushed her leg and she took a long time regain its full use. She never did make that film but returned to the concert stage achieving the same reputation in the Americas that she had in Europe. During the war, for some reason she settled in Mexico where she made one more film and then gave herself exclusively to the concert stage until her retirement. Having married an MD she settled in Los Angeles where she was a member of the city’s social scene before her death in 1980. Again, I can only thank heaven that she made this film so that I could appreciate a great musical artist in her prime.
I hope if you have a chance to see the film and most especially The Tale OF The Vienna Woods sequence, you will experience the kind of joy I do whenever I watch this sequence. As far as I am concerned it could go on and forever. It is a neglected masterpiece.
i AM IN TOTAL AGREEMENT WITH THIS REVIEW. IT IS ALSO A BLESSING THAT KORJUS’ VOICE IS REPLENDENT DUE TO FILM RECORDING WHICH GIVES A TRUER QUALITY THAN HER EARLIER AND LATER STUDIO RECORDINGS. i AM NOW 86 AND FIRST HEARD HER IN A 1945 SET OF RCA RECORDS SINGING STRAUS WALTZES.. OVER THE YEARS I MANAGED TO COLLECT VIRTUALLY ALL OF HER
EUROPEAN AND AMERICAN RECORDINGS. AS FOR THE MOVIE ITSELF, IT IS STILL ONE FILM THAT, EVEN AFTER AT LEAST 30 VIEWINGS OF IT, STILL GET SO EMOTIONALLY INVOLED WITH TEARS FLOWING FREELY . IT WAS AT IT’S 1957 THEATRE RE-RELASE THAT I FIRST SAW IT. MILIZA IS ONE SOPRANO THAT I
ALMOST CONSIDER DIVINE, REACHING SOULS LIKE A GRACE FROM THE GOOD LORD. ( OCTOBER 2021)
i AM IN TOTAL AGREEMENT WITH THIS REVIEW. IT IS ALSO A BLESSING THAT KORJUS’ VOICE IS REPLENDENT DUE TO FILM RECORDING WHICH GIVES A TRUER QUALITY THAN HER EARLIER AND LATER STUDIO RECORDINGS. i AM NOW 86 AND FIRST HEARD HER IN A 1945 SET OF RCA RECORDS SINGING STRAUSS WALTZES.. OVER THE YEARS I MANAGED TO COLLECT VIRTUALLY ALL OF HER
EUROPEAN AND AMERICAN RECORDINGS. AS FOR THE MOVIE ITSELF, IT IS ONE FILM THAT, EVEN AFTER AT LEAST 30 VIEWINGS OF IT, STILL GET SO EMOTIONALLY INVOLVED THAT TEARS FLOW FREELY. IT WAS AT IT’S 1957 THEATRE RE-RELASE THAT I FIRST SAW IT. MILIZA IS ONE SOPRANO THAT I ALMOST CONSIDER DIVINE, REACHING SOULS LIKE A GRACE FROM THE GOOD LORD. HER SINGING TECHNIQUE IS BEYOND BELIEF AND HER LOOKS, TOTALLY CAPTIVATING. ( OCTOBER 2021)
Thank you so much. I never thought anyone would ever want to read this piece as the film has become rather obscure and rarely shown even on TCM. In certain ways it was a film far too sophisticated for 1937 audiences who didn’t realize they were watching an operetta in the form of highly fictionalized biography. Be that as it may, the Vienna Woods sequence remains a sheer delight viewing after viewing. One of the greatest musical sequences of its kind ever made. When I watch this sequence it is usually four or five times in a row. I simply cant get enough of it. As for Korjus her singing is pure magic and as a film performer she is a delight. Her charm as a performer exudes in every scene she is in. Although it is a tragedy that she didn’t make more films, at least we have her in “The Great Waltz” at the height of her power and that should be seen as a gift to be grateful for. Fortunately MGM even in in the 30w 40s and 50s made a great effort to preserve their films and so the prints we see today are, for the most part, pristine and look much as they did when the film was released. Thanks much for your comments they are much appreciated and it is ever so nice to find someone else who appreciates “Miss Miliza” as much I do. If I was to use one phrase to describe her, it would be a gift of the gods.
Hello Joseph..and thank you for your generous response. Pray forgive me if I add more information about my love of Miliza. A lifelong blind gentleman friend and wonderful musician with perfect pitch- neighbour in the small village we lived in, had amassed a substantial collection of old 78 rpm shellacs. c. 1949 .( I was 14 then)…He would often invite friends to his home and share with them a listening of his newest purchases . As i mentioned, it was at his home that I first heard Miliza. Move ahead to when I was attending University in Edmonton, Alberta , in 1957. My friend had moved
to the city as well. He was a piano tuner and had many new clients there. One day he got a phone call from the owner of a motel with night club attached. He wanted to have the piano tuned. Once the tuning completed, the owner chanced to ask my friend if he knew of Miliza Korjus. Responding in the affirmative the owner said that his brother was visiting from California and that he was married to Miliza. In minutes the three of them were having a monumental exchange about music, singing etc. The brother, a physician ,explained that Miliza had recently formed her own recording company in LA (Venus Records), she being disappointed that RCA had snubbed her request they re-issue on vinyl, more of her earlier recordings. Dr .Walter Shecter then went to his room and returned with a sealed
album of Miliza’s newest release and made a gift of it to my blind friend. This was in 1965!. Sadly my dear friend passed in 1983 and I inherited his record collection. Needless to say, that Venus record is part of my treasured records by Miliza. Small world, isn’t it!.